I have to say this. It will probably stir up trouble, but hey! It's my blog so get over it! Yeah, I've got an attitude tonight. What about it?!
This has been bugging me for a month or so now. When I took Kieren to her friend Sarah's birthday party at Build A Bear, Kieren made a really cute pink kitty. Appropriately named Kitty, of course. Well, Kieren wanted a "baby" for Kitty. She kept going over to the little buddy stuffed animals and looking at them. She really loved one of the little dogs! As I was telling her she could get it, one of the sales people came over. She looked at the little dog, looked at Kitty, and then looked at Kieren. She grabbed a little kitty that looked like Kieren's big one and handed it to Kieren. She told Kieren, "You don't want the doggie. The little kitty goes with the big one! They match!" and she took the doggie. I was shocked! Kieren, being two, was fine with it. I wasn't! I tried to correct the girl, but she walked away. I couldn't do anything about it because Kieren decided that was fine and I didn't see the woman again to chew her out.
WTF?! Why did the little pink kitty HAVE TO match the big kitty? What gave this woman the right to force this choice? Force this identity?! This was like saying, "You have to look like alike. The big pink Kitty can only have a little pink kitty. The blond woman shouldn't have the small Asian child. Quick! Someone bring me a blond child and put this one back! Ahhh! That's better. Now they match!" I'm so glad Kieren is too young to notice or ask questions.
Along the same lines of the Build A Bear incident, I was looking at dolls with Kieren the other day. Why do so many people think that baby-dolls need to look like their owners? I know people who will only buy Asian dolls for their Asian daughters. They wonder why the child would want a doll that doesn't look like her.
I admit that Kieren has 3 Chinese dolls we bought for her in China. We bought them in China. Of course they are Asian looking. We wanted her to have dolls from her birth country. My mom bought Kieren a full-size Asian Cabbage Patch doll for Christmas. It's on Kieren's shelf in her room. The clothes actually match the room so it's really cute as a decoration. And Kieren's favorite doll, Baby, is somewhat Asian looking. She is a Cabbage Patch Baby. We bought her because she was just the right size for a 2-year-old and she's washable. The Asian features were just because. Any other dolls Kieren gets from us from now on, will be Kieren's choice.
Kieren doesn't see that she looks different yet. She sees her white-blond brother with his violet-blue eyes. She sees her Daddy with light brown (and gray!) hair and hazel eyes. She sees me and Nanny with dark blond hair and green eyes. She sees her Uncle Sean with dark brown hair and dark brown eyes. She sees Pops with silver hair and bright blue eyes. Pops and I have wavy/curly hair. Her Daddy, Nanny, & Uncle Sean have very straight hair. It will be interesting to see what her dolls will look like! Will she choose a doll that looks Asian like herself? Or will she choose one with blond hair and blue eye like Cullen? It will be completely up to Kieren.
I know most people mean well. They think that by having a doll look like the child it is reinforcing who they are. But doesn't this send a mixed message? Isn't this saying you have to match?! This isn't how our family looks! We all look very different. Cullen's hair and eyes don't match mine or Andy's. Uncle Sean is a genetic reject! My Great-Grandfather was an American Indian. Sean got his recessive genes. My hair and eyes are kind of the same color as Nanny's, but we don't look anything alike and my hair is wavy like Pops! Why would Kieren want to get dolls that only look like her? This isn't what she see!
I don't think Kieren has any stuffed animals (other than Mickey & Minnie Mouse and the pink kitties) that match. She doesn't care! They don't have to look alike! It doesn't matter to her! Why should it matter to anyone else?!
10 comments:
Sophia doesn't care much to play with dolls, but she has a mixture. I see no preference there. With that said though, she will look at a picture in a magazine of an Asian kiddo and say 'she looks like me!' She will be 3 next week, and is noticing little things like that, but no major issue, for sure. We don't see many Asian people, but in person she doesn't seem to notice.
It shouldn't.
My girls have Asian babies but their fave is Oprah(no offence intended) a very beautiful black baby. My children see color but it makes no difference to them, they seem oblivious.
I have always taught them there are many different skin, eye and hair color and all are beautiful, we don't all match and we don't have to.
I am so proud of my children and how they have taught me to live outside the box, wish everyone else could.
As far as the ignorant saleslady, she needed to listen to her little customer, she knew what she wanted. Customer is ALWAYS RIGHT. :O)
Maybe she will be like Jake and not see the differences for a long time. He is 4 and has not asked one question about such things. He just accepts people as they are.
Oh how I want that quality his personality to last forever!
Man I feel sorry for that lady- what a narrow mind to live inside. Can you imagine? Ignorance is not bliss...
I say live and let live....it bugs me when someones imposes their views on another.
I will fess up that I have Asian dolls waiting but I also have Raggedy Ann, Dressy-Bessy and some blondies too. For all I know she may shun them all and prefer a Tonka trunk. So be it.
Amen to that post Sam. I too admit that Maddy has two asian doll babies (neither of which she cares for at all) but she also has a red headed dressy bessy and a blue-eyed, no hair baby. Again, right now she doesn't like any of them. I too will let her choose what she wants because you are right, our family is not just asian.. we are heinz 57.
I agree that children should have an assortment of different looking dolls. I also agree that as our girls get old enough to have preferences, they should get to choose. What would bother me is if Linlee didn't have any dolls that looked like her. What sort of message would that send? I'm just thankful we aren't raising our Chinese daughters thirty years ago when finding an Asian looking doll would have been next to impossible.
Part of the doll issue is from studies done in the African American community that teach children to define beauty. that is why it is important to surround your child of dolls that look like her so she gets a sense of what is beautiful like her. They are very famous studies.
Now in regards to the kitty/cat issue, the build a bear employee should be more sensitive.
Beverly
I am so with you, Sam!!
I have kids that "match" me and Kevin.. they lose their identity and start thinking they can only identify with the parent that looks like them.
Jenna, on the other hand, thinks she's "mommy AND daddy's baby" and she tells us all the time..
Laurie
I hate "matchy" anything. We all are individual and should be respected for that.
Post a Comment